Item: ONJR25OCGA079

Original U.S. Civil War J.H. Merrill M1858 Breech Loading Cavalry Carbine Converted to Muzzle Loading Short Rifle - Serial 5290

In stock

Regular price $1,095.00

Lifetime Authenticity

Lifetime Authenticity Guarantee

We ensure our artifacts are genuine, giving buyers long-term confidence in value and historical accuracy.

Learn More
Lifetime Authenticity

Have military antiques you want to sell?

We pay top dollar! Click the link below to get started.

Sell your items

Manufactured prior to 1899 – legally recognized as an antique firearm under U.S. federal law. Not classified as a modern firearm; therefore, no federal license or FFL transfer is required. Eligible for shipment to all U.S. states and over 25 countries internationally via UPS, subject to local laws and import regulations.

  • Original Item: One of a Kind. This is a very interesting example of what was originlly a percussion breech loading Civil War Saddle Ring Carbine. As they use both a cap and a type of breech loaded cartridge, they are often referred to as "capping breech loaders". Somewhere around 14,500 were made by J.H. Merrill of Baltimore for the Union Cavalry, mostly between 1863 and 1865. The carbines were produced in two versions: First Type and Second Type. The First Type included a brass patch box in the stock and had the breech lever secured by a flat, knurled latch. The Second Type was produced without the patch box and had the breech lever secured with a rounded, button type latch. The majority of the carbines, something over 10,000 were of the First Type, with the Second Type coming in during July 1864 and accounting for about 4,100. The breech loading design is somewhat unique: a breech loading percussion system with a large breech lever / loading rammer. Percussion cartridges were loaded, pushed forward into the breech by the rammer, and then ignited by a percussion cap.


    This example is however no longer a breech loader, having been converted to a Muzzle loader, most likely for sporting or hunting use. The breech loading system was not without its drawbacks, and it most likely would be damaged over the long term by fouling and wear. As such the breech loading components were locked in place, and we think we can see a ground off pin used to secure the breech lever in placed on the top of the receiver. As there is no longer any way to open the breech, we do not know what type of internal modifications were made. Additionally, We noted that the stock, or in particular the butt stock, looks to have been refit with the brass butt plate and patch box from a Sharps Model 1853 carbine or similar, as it is definitely not correct for a Merrill. The barrel was also replaced, possibly with a shortened barrel from a Merrill Rifle, or perhaps something entirely different. Really a very interesting modified examples, the likes of which we have not seen before!


    This fine example bears serial number 5290 on the lock, while the modified breech lever is marked with 5326 on the back. The serial number for this would usually have put it into the "Type I" range, but as the breech lever lock has been removed, there is no way to tell. The lock plate still has the original markings, which are still crisp:


    J.H. MERRILL BALTO.
    PAT JULY 1858.
    APL. 9. MAY 21-28-61


    The metal components, originally blued, now show a worn gray patina, with some areas retaining the finish better than others after years of cleaning cleaning. We did not see any major oxidation or past pitting, just the usual wear from age. The original rear sight was removed, and replaced with a simple tangent sight, while the front sight was also replaced, however the blade on the replacement broke off. The lock is still functional, though a strong pull at half cock can cause it to discharge. The bore is in very good condition, showing a bright finish with crisp lands and grooves. We did note that the muzzle was counterbored about 3/8" of the way in to remove the rifling, often thought to increase accuracy by removing the rifling at the muzzle, which would be worn by cleaning / ramming.


    The stock is in lovely condition, looking to have been varnished at some point in the past, and it is fitted with a white metal nose cap, as seen on sporting rifles of the time. It has a beautiful color, showing only light wear and no repairs or other damage. There is a very nice brass fitted steel ramrod under the barrel, which is definitely not original. It is threaded on the narrow end so tools could have been used with it. There are no sling attachments on the rifle, and as mentioned previously, the saddle ring bar and ring were removed, though the bases are still present to secure the lock and other components.


    A very interesting post war conversion of a Merrill Breech-loading carbine, probably intended for sporting use. Ready to research and display!


    Specifications-


    Years of Manufacture: mid 1864 - Modified later
    Caliber:  .54
    Ammunition Type: Cap and Ball
    Barrel Length: 26 1/2 inches
    Overall Length: 42 1/4 inches
    Action: Muzzle Loading
    Feed System: Single Shot


    NOTE: International orders of antique firearms MUST be shipped using UPS WW Services (courier). USPS Priority Mail international will not accept these. International customers should always consult their country's antique gun laws prior to ordering.


  • This product is not available for shipping in US state(s): New Jersey

    This product is available for international shipping.
  • Not eligible for payment with Paypal or Amazon

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, in most jurisdictions, antique firearms are legal to own and are generally not subject to the same regulatory requirements as modern firearms. Under U.S. federal law, any firearm manufactured on or before December 31, 1898, is classified as an antique firearm and is not considered a firearm under the Gun Control Act of 1968. As such, no federal license or FFL (Federal Firearms License) transfer is required for purchase or possession. Antique firearms may be legally shipped to all U.S. states and to over 25 countries worldwide via UPS, subject to applicable shipping and import/export restrictions. Please note: Firearms laws vary by country, state, and locality, and are subject to change. It is your responsibility to consult with local law enforcement or a qualified legal professional to ensure compliance with all relevant laws and regulations in your area.

We Buy Military Antiques

Our team expert buyers travels the world to pay fair prices for entire estate collections to singular items.

START SELLING TODAY